Nov. 30, 2025

Guerrilla Scholarship: Breaking Academic Boundaries with Dr. Sheldon Greaves

Guerrilla Scholarship: Breaking Academic Boundaries with Dr. Sheldon Greaves

What happens when passionate curiosity meets unconventional research methods? Dr. Sheldon Greaves reveals the power of "guerrilla scholarship," which is a creative approach to intellectual work that flourishes outside traditional academic walls.

For instructional designers, educators, or anyone seeking to pursue intellectual work without institutional backing, this episode provides both practical guidance and inspiring possibilities. Dr. Greaves reminds us that meaningful learning thrives in community, where diverse perspectives come together to explore questions academia might overlook.

🔗 Website and Social Links:

Please visit Dr. Sheldon Greaves’ social media links below.

Sheldon’s Facebook Page

Sheldon’s LinkedIn Page

Sheldon’s Substack Page 

Send Jackie a Text

Join PodMatch!
Use the link to join PodMatch, a place for hosts and guests to connect.

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.

Support the show

💟 Designing with Love + allows you to support the show by keeping the mic on and the ideas flowing. Click on the link above to provide your support.

Buy Me a Coffee is another way you can support the show, either as a one-time gift or through a monthly subscription.

🗣️ Want to be a guest on Designing with Love? Send Jackie Pelegrin a message on PodMatch, here: Be a guest on the show

🌐 Check out the show's website here: Designing with Love

📱 Send a text to the show by clicking the Send Jackie a Text link above.

👍🏼 Please make sure to like and share this episode with others. Here's to great learning!

 

00:00 - Introduction to Dr. Sheldon Greaves

11:04 - Academic Journey and Teaching Spies

13:36 - Creative Learning on a Shoestring

23:02 - Guerrilla Scholarship Explained

29:55 - 14-Year-Old Scholar Takes Down Professor

38:31 - Independent Scholars and Their Impact

39:39 - The State of Modern Education

WEBVTT

00:00:01.040 --> 00:00:04.107
Hello and welcome to the Designing with Love podcast.

00:00:04.107 --> 00:00:11.753
I am your host, Jackie Pelegrin, where my goal is to bring you information, tips, and tricks as an instructional designer.

00:00:11.753 --> 00:00:19.341
Hello instructional designers and educators, welcome to episode 68 of the Designing with Love podcast.

00:00:19.341 --> 00:00:23.810
I'm thrilled to have Dr Sheldon Greaves, an author and educator, with me today.

00:00:23.810 --> 00:00:24.693
Welcome, Sheldon.

00:00:25.359 --> 00:00:26.995
Hi, Jackie, it's a pleasure to have Dr Sheldon Greaves, an author and educator, with me today.

00:00:26.995 --> 00:00:27.173
Welcome, Sheldon.

00:00:27.173 --> 00:00:27.390
Hi, Jackie, it's a pleasure to be here.

00:00:27.820 --> 00:00:28.806
Yes, thank you so much.

00:00:28.806 --> 00:00:33.244
I'm glad we got connected on PodMatch and had an opportunity to do this interview today.

00:00:33.244 --> 00:00:34.226
I'm excited.

00:00:34.226 --> 00:00:39.448
I'm looking forward to us getting into the deep dive of everything, so it'll be great.

00:00:39.448 --> 00:00:40.331
I'm looking forward to it.

00:00:40.331 --> 00:00:45.807
To start, can you tell us a little bit about yourself and share what inspired you to focus on the education field?

00:00:46.868 --> 00:00:51.655
Well, I have always been very passionate about learning, mostly.

00:00:51.655 --> 00:00:58.000
Well, I guess it's trendy to blame your parents for a lot of things, and I guess I can do that in this case.

00:00:58.581 --> 00:00:59.720
There you go.

00:00:59.720 --> 00:01:06.506
My parents were both college graduates, my mother in particular.

00:01:06.506 --> 00:01:09.548
She graduated with a degree in English.

00:01:09.548 --> 00:01:10.707
She had a fairly wide view of the world.

00:01:10.707 --> 00:01:48.460
My father had traveled fairly extensively in Europe and the Middle East before he settled down, so there was a great deal of awareness that there's a big, beautiful world out there world out there.

00:01:48.460 --> 00:02:09.502
My mother also was a huge fan of the public library, which served both as kind of a ersatz educator and occasional daycare where she would drop me at the public library, and she also made a point of ensuring that there were lots of books in the house, and that's a habit that kind of stuck with me.

00:02:09.502 --> 00:02:12.147
I can't get enough of books.

00:02:12.147 --> 00:02:13.610
My wife is the same way.

00:02:13.610 --> 00:02:24.248
It's not entirely true that I married her for her library, and so I have always been kind of passionate about it, and so I have always been kind of passionate about it.

00:02:25.289 --> 00:03:17.407
Going through school, I finally finished with a doctorate in Near Eastern Studies from UC Berkeley, and while I kind of soured on the whole academic scene and there weren't any jobs anyway, but I still was very passionate about learning and education, and so I found other ways to exercise that passion working in the nonprofit sector, in citizen science, and I also, by a very strange chain of events, found myself as a co-founder of Henley Putnam University, which was the first private university that was designed from the ground up to offer programs to the intelligence, counterterrorism and executive protection industries.

00:03:17.407 --> 00:03:30.808
So I was basically training spies for a few years, which turned out to be just an incredible experience and a real lesson in how the university system works.

00:03:30.808 --> 00:03:34.040
You learn a lot about a university by building one.

00:03:34.663 --> 00:03:37.308
Right, exactly, you learn the inner workings of it.

00:03:37.308 --> 00:03:43.508
Yeah, it's more than an educational system, it's a business that has to operate.

00:03:43.508 --> 00:04:02.146
Yeah, those inner workings of it, yeah, and then you kind of see the all the different elements that go into it, of the financial side of it, and then the government side of it, you know, especially for undergraduate students, and Pell grants and scholarships and loans, all that good stuff, yeah.

00:04:02.867 --> 00:04:13.129
And privacy and policies and all the stuff that you've got to come up with to make sure that you prove that you know how to run a university.

00:04:13.129 --> 00:05:02.146
Well, I also had to do my doctorate rather on a shoestring, because while I was doing my doctorate, my wife was doing hers at Stanford in classics, and so we were effectively a young married couple putting two kids through college namely each other and so we had to get creative, and one of the things we did, for example, was that after her scholarship ran out I didn't get one, because she's smarter than I am we would take turns, I would go to school and she would work full time, and then I would take a financial leave of absence, get a job, she would go to school and we'd just trade off and we eventually made it.

00:05:02.146 --> 00:05:05.125
I mean, we eventually did both finish and we're still married.

00:05:05.125 --> 00:05:07.872
So I guess that says something about how that works.

00:05:08.634 --> 00:05:17.031
But when I wasn't in school formally, I still had to keep up with what I was doing and I still had stuff I wanted to research.

00:05:17.031 --> 00:05:26.579
And that's where you kind of had to get creative because I didn't always have access to the usual things that I would have had had I been a student.

00:05:26.579 --> 00:05:34.675
And that continued after I graduated and I still wanted to do stuff but didn't have access to a university.

00:05:35.259 --> 00:05:48.791
So that formed the basis of my latest book, which is about how to do interesting and useful intellectual work when you don't have access to the tools of academia.

00:05:49.660 --> 00:05:50.562
Wow, that's great.

00:05:50.562 --> 00:06:01.250
I love the story of you and your wife, how you both were able to work that out and really really come to an agreement right, and say, okay, you do it for this period and then I'll take a break.

00:06:01.250 --> 00:06:15.440
And you figured out a way to make it work, and make it work in different ways, so that you both probably wouldn't burn out, right, if you're both going at the same time and then trying to care for your family and your children and everything that wouldn't have worked.

00:06:15.922 --> 00:06:18.026
Well, we didn't have kids, but we did have cats.

00:06:18.326 --> 00:06:22.324
So Okay, well, that's yeah, and they, they have their own needs, right they?

00:06:22.363 --> 00:06:26.673
have their needs and they will let you know when you don't meet them Exactly.

00:06:27.100 --> 00:06:31.788
They can be, they're independent, but they still need care.

00:06:31.908 --> 00:06:32.449
They need help.

00:06:32.449 --> 00:06:33.891
Yeah, they need care.

00:06:34.031 --> 00:06:34.552
Absolutely.

00:06:34.552 --> 00:06:35.834
Yeah, that's great.

00:06:35.834 --> 00:06:36.535
Well, I love that.

00:06:36.535 --> 00:06:40.446
I love that your parents had that.

00:06:40.446 --> 00:06:49.105
Like your mom and your dad had that travel bug in them and they loved to explore and everything, because that sounds like my grandparents.

00:06:49.105 --> 00:06:51.812
They loved to travel too and they kind of put that in me.

00:06:51.812 --> 00:06:53.122
So I love learning.

00:06:53.122 --> 00:06:56.132
I don't know different languages, but I love to read too.

00:06:56.132 --> 00:06:58.968
So I have that affinity for reading books.

00:06:58.968 --> 00:07:03.146
So I would read mystery books when I was growing up, so I can relate to that.

00:07:03.146 --> 00:07:04.930
I would read Nancy Drew Hardy Boys when I was growing up, so I can relate to that.

00:07:04.930 --> 00:07:08.127
I would read Nancy Drew Hardy Boys when I was growing up in the summertime.

00:07:08.127 --> 00:07:10.252
So my friend and I would trade books and we would.

00:07:10.252 --> 00:07:16.286
She would read one and I would read one, and then we'd trade and we'd talk, read each other's and then talk about it afterwards.

00:07:16.346 --> 00:07:17.930
So it was pretty neat, so you had a book exchange.

00:07:18.519 --> 00:07:19.360
Yeah, exactly.

00:07:19.461 --> 00:07:22.324
So I would collect the Nancy Drew, she would collect the Hardy Boys.

00:07:22.324 --> 00:07:25.350
So we each didn't have to buy books and we saved on that.

00:07:25.350 --> 00:07:26.350
So it was fun.

00:07:26.350 --> 00:07:29.194
Yeah, it was a neat, neat idea, Definitely.

00:07:29.194 --> 00:07:32.627
So it's nice when you can be creative like that and and do those things.

00:07:32.627 --> 00:07:33.369
That's great.

00:07:33.369 --> 00:07:35.132
Wow, I love that.

00:07:35.132 --> 00:07:38.324
So, yeah, that's, that's a great way to open up.

00:07:38.324 --> 00:07:40.226
You know about what you were talking about with your book.

00:07:40.226 --> 00:07:43.892
So you talk about in your book about guerrilla scholarship.

00:07:43.892 --> 00:07:46.101
So can you kind of talk a little bit about that?

00:07:46.101 --> 00:07:47.625
Maybe give us an example of that?

00:07:48.206 --> 00:07:48.848
Yeah, that's.

00:07:48.848 --> 00:07:54.305
Guerrilla scholarship is my designation, something I coined many years ago.

00:07:54.305 --> 00:08:05.011
That is basically doing intellectual work by using creative and unconventional approaches to finding and working with information.

00:08:05.011 --> 00:08:07.682
That's one half of it.

00:08:07.682 --> 00:08:21.343
It tends to ignore disciplinary boundaries and it allows people to look at areas of study and inquiry that are often ignored by academics.

00:08:21.343 --> 00:08:39.705
Not because academia is wrong or bad, it's simply they only get to look at what they can find funding for Right and that creates kind of a small pocket where all the research gets done and there's a whole bunch of stuff that just doesn't get touched.

00:08:40.046 --> 00:08:51.782
Side of guerrilla scholarship is a deep appreciation and concern for doing so in a way that benefits the community.

00:08:51.782 --> 00:09:42.298
You form learning communities, you get people together and you have salons and seminars and teach-ins, or just get a few people together at the coffee shop and you talk about stuff and the idea is that, like the guerrilla combatant, that kind of guerrilla can only succeed if they have the support of the surrounding community Right Right From time to time.

00:09:42.298 --> 00:09:56.486
Well, in numerous cases, the founding fathers repeatedly emphasized the importance of education in the citizenry, and I always turn to Dwight Eisenhower's farewell address.

00:09:56.486 --> 00:09:59.905
This is the one where he gave us the phrase military-industrial complex.

00:09:59.905 --> 00:10:01.657
That's what everybody remembers.

00:10:01.657 --> 00:10:19.846
But he also said that the industrial military complex can only be held in check by quote an alert and knowledgeable citizenry, and so that's another reason why I'm kind of well a little exercised about this.

00:10:20.827 --> 00:10:22.409
That's neat, yeah, I like that.

00:10:22.409 --> 00:10:23.696
So we don't do it in isolation.

00:10:23.696 --> 00:10:24.537
That's neat, yeah, I like that.

00:10:24.537 --> 00:10:25.157
So we don't do it in isolation.

00:10:25.157 --> 00:10:36.506
We do it surrounded with other like-minded individuals or people that we may not know much about their area of expertise and we can draw upon their experiences and then we can learn from each other.

00:10:36.787 --> 00:11:15.106
So it's a community approach to being able to learn and grow no-transcript ideas and methods and things like that and talk about it and then just do it over lunch.

00:11:15.106 --> 00:11:16.097
So that way we weren't.

00:11:16.097 --> 00:11:22.399
I mean, it was taking time away from their lunch hour, but we were like, bring your brown bag lunch and just come in.

00:11:22.399 --> 00:11:29.470
You know, if you want to learn while you're at lunch, instead of just sitting in the cafeteria or sitting in the break room, come on, come in.

00:11:29.470 --> 00:11:30.797
And so it was nice.

00:11:30.937 --> 00:11:34.606
Yeah, that's a wonderful example of how, of how this can be done.

00:12:12.605 --> 00:12:13.128
That's great.

00:12:13.128 --> 00:12:22.673
Yeah, do you have any examples of where you've seen it uh, that guerrilla scholarship really effective in what you've been working on, maybe in the past or maybe what you're working on now?

00:12:23.575 --> 00:12:39.634
Well, there's an example that I like to point to just as an example of being creative and unconventional, and this is the example of a 14-year-old eighth grader named Rebecca Freed.

00:12:39.634 --> 00:12:53.897
Eighth grader named Rebecca Freed whose father would print off I guess he worked at an office, a law office, and he would occasionally print off articles that he thought his kids would find interesting and bring them home.

00:12:53.897 --> 00:13:22.995
One of the articles that he printed was about a paper that had been published by a scholar by the name of Richard Jensen, and the paper claimed that the idea in Irish immigration that there were all these signs and ads that said no Irish need apply, that it was a myth, that this didn't really happen.

00:13:22.995 --> 00:13:28.517
Well, he brought this home and Rebecca read the article and she thought that seemed a little weird.

00:13:28.517 --> 00:13:45.125
So she jumped onto Google Google Images and she started searching and she immediately started finding these old period photographs of shop fronts with signs that said no Irish need apply, and this kind of piqued her interest.

00:13:45.245 --> 00:13:53.386
So she continued to dig and eventually she got a hold of another gentleman by the name of Kirby Miller.

00:13:53.386 --> 00:14:04.148
He was a retired professor who specialized in immigration issues, and he happened to disagree with Jensen's thesis, and she went to him and she says have I got something here?

00:14:04.148 --> 00:14:08.355
And Miller goes yeah, absolutely, you've got.

00:14:08.355 --> 00:14:10.179
This is great stuff.

00:14:10.179 --> 00:14:37.072
So what he did was he helped her assemble what she had done and fill in the gaps and turn her little scattered body of research into a real rigorous paper, which was then submitted for peer review and published in exactly in the very journal that Jensen had published his original paper in.

00:14:37.072 --> 00:14:44.512
And, you know, it just completely knocked the pins out from under this guy's thesis, which I guess is not something I mean.

00:14:44.512 --> 00:14:49.899
No scholar likes to have his thesis toppled, let alone by an eighth grader.

00:14:50.421 --> 00:15:09.913
Right curiosity flow, but also hooking up with people who have the skills to take what you've done and show you how to turn it into real-life scholarship.

00:15:09.913 --> 00:15:14.990
I mean, if she had just posted these things on social media, it wouldn't have made any difference at all.

00:15:14.990 --> 00:15:23.256
But as it happens, she ended up making a significant contribution to the field of immigration studies.

00:15:24.585 --> 00:15:43.170
Wow, that's amazing, and at 14 years old she was able to take that, yeah, and really, because I would imagine a 14 year old wouldn't be able to probably have that, maybe not that capacity to be able to follow that through right, Because I know when I was that age I didn't want to.

00:15:43.170 --> 00:15:50.474
I, I, there were things I wanted to do but I didn't necessarily follow through with them because then something else would pique my interest and move on.

00:15:50.474 --> 00:15:51.476
Yeah, so that's hard.

00:15:51.764 --> 00:15:55.434
Well, when I, when I was 14, I I had no idea what peer review was.

00:15:55.434 --> 00:15:57.867
I had no idea what an academic journal was.

00:15:57.867 --> 00:16:10.557
You know, I mean the, the most, uh, advanced thing that I would read would be, like you know, of that sort would be, you know, news magazines like you know, time or, or newsweek, or that sort of stuff.

00:16:10.764 --> 00:16:21.756
I mean, I think that that was it, but yeah yeah more of a casual reading type of things that you could do on a sunday morning or something, yeah, exactly, wow, that's a great example.

00:16:21.756 --> 00:16:22.317
I love that.

00:16:22.317 --> 00:16:36.547
And so it shows that age and talent is no barrier, because you can, like you said, hook up with someone that has that capability and that experience to be able to take it to the next level and bring it to maybe, or maybe bring it to the finish line.

00:16:36.547 --> 00:16:42.295
You know, if you've got something, you know it's not quite ready, you can have someone kind of help you with that.

00:16:42.355 --> 00:16:49.819
Yeah, and you know this also points out something else, and that is that there are an awful lot of people out there who used to be in academia.

00:16:49.819 --> 00:16:50.863
They're not anymore.

00:16:50.863 --> 00:17:18.874
Maybe they got disillusioned, maybe they retired, maybe they decided they wanted to do something else, but there's this huge I believe untapped reservoir out there of intellectual talent and expertise that I think in many cases, is just kind of waiting or looking for an opportunity to do something with their stuff, or would love to dust something off and see what happens.

00:17:18.874 --> 00:17:32.250
And I'm kind of hoping that what this book will do is that it will inspire some of these people to kind of come out of the woodwork and and, uh, you know, see what they can see, see what they can do with what they've got.

00:17:32.250 --> 00:17:35.759
Uh, you know, in 2025 or 2026.

00:17:36.345 --> 00:17:36.786
That's great.

00:17:36.786 --> 00:17:50.951
Yeah, I've got your book on my list of books to get because I think that's, yeah, I think it's really great because, yeah, I mean, for a long time I've I've thought about writing a book myself and but I thought that's just too too far out there.

00:17:50.951 --> 00:17:54.307
I well and it's funny too because I thought I couldn't teach college courses.

00:17:54.307 --> 00:17:57.493
I thought, nah, that's, I'm not, that, I'm not a teacher.

00:17:57.493 --> 00:18:03.064
And here I am four years and it's just, you know, past that four year mark of teaching college courses.

00:18:03.064 --> 00:18:05.752
So I thought, if I can do that right.

00:18:05.772 --> 00:18:08.026
You know then then and so now.

00:18:08.026 --> 00:18:12.136
The book is that it's around 220 pages now.

00:18:12.136 --> 00:18:16.492
And so yeah yeah, so in a week's time I was around.

00:18:16.492 --> 00:18:18.010
It's about yeah, I was about a week and a half.

00:18:18.010 --> 00:18:24.914
I was able to take all the different content from the podcast episodes the solo ones that form the basis of the book.

00:18:25.435 --> 00:18:28.566
And so yeah, so it was existing content that was already there.

00:18:28.566 --> 00:18:44.514
It was just putting it into a different format, adding different things to it to give them some reflection, and so it's a combination of academics, so it's like that academic side of it models, theories, but then also the practical application.

00:18:44.514 --> 00:18:51.285
So that way it's and you know there's so many great books out there that have some of that in there.

00:18:51.285 --> 00:19:06.884
But hopefully this will provide a unique lens from that and people will be able to use it that are thinking of going into the field or want, you know, to, even just generally in education, if they're not sure if they want to go into education.

00:19:06.884 --> 00:19:15.832
I think it's a great way to be able to do that, because these models and theories aren't just for instructional design, they're across different sectors within education just in general.

00:19:15.832 --> 00:19:19.916
And I think it's a great way to be able to do that, because these models and theories aren't just for instructional design, they're across different sectors within education just in general.

00:19:19.916 --> 00:19:20.757
So hopefully it'll be a good resource.

00:19:20.778 --> 00:19:21.317
That sounds great.

00:19:21.317 --> 00:19:22.519
I look forward to seeing it.

00:19:23.720 --> 00:19:28.611
Yeah, me too, and I even have a proposal that I put together and crafted that.

00:19:28.611 --> 00:19:33.705
So if I want to go with a hybrid know like a hybrid publisher or something like that, then at least I've got.

00:19:33.705 --> 00:19:35.855
It's about 10 pages, so it's not too long.

00:19:35.914 --> 00:19:42.251
It's got a sample chapter and it's got some you know the author biography in there and market research.

00:19:42.251 --> 00:19:50.584
I, you know, did some research to see what, what does the industry look like and and where's that at, so that you know publishers could see that it's a good return on investment.

00:19:50.584 --> 00:19:51.505
Cause you know how that goes.

00:19:51.505 --> 00:19:58.627
You, you have to be able to pitch your book and it's a it's a whole marketing plan that you have to show that you have that.

00:19:58.627 --> 00:20:06.147
And I was like, okay, I better show I have that social presence and that ecosystem that I can build around it and and market it.

00:20:06.147 --> 00:20:13.044
So you know, I mean publishers will help you do that, but at the same time, the author needs to kind of do some of that legwork too.

00:20:13.044 --> 00:20:15.086
So that's important.

00:20:15.086 --> 00:20:28.096
That's great, yeah, so, as we know, there's been many changes in education over the last several years, probably even because of just AI, but different other things have impacted that.

00:20:28.096 --> 00:20:31.799
How would you describe the state of education today generally?

00:20:32.924 --> 00:20:34.050
have impacted that?

00:20:34.050 --> 00:20:35.859
How would you describe the state of education today generally?

00:20:35.859 --> 00:20:57.947
Well, that's a really interesting question because for the last couple of years I've been working as a substitute and a personal care assistant and an educational assistant at the school district here in Albany, oregon, and I've seen a lot of things and I have, you know, all grades K through 12, wherever they needed me.

00:20:57.947 --> 00:20:58.890
That's where they stuck me.

00:20:58.890 --> 00:21:03.363
Also, a lot with behavior support and special ed.

00:21:03.363 --> 00:21:13.872
I am in absolute awe of what school teachers do with what they have.

00:21:13.872 --> 00:21:17.996
It's just amazing to me.

00:21:17.996 --> 00:21:27.000
I feel like, quite honestly, the way teachers generally are regarded in this country is a national disgrace.

00:21:27.000 --> 00:21:30.564
I don't think they are paid nearly enough.

00:21:30.564 --> 00:21:32.467
Let's look frankly.

00:21:32.467 --> 00:21:42.221
Until we start paying school teachers a six-figure salary, let's not even pretend that we're serious about education Schools.

00:21:42.221 --> 00:21:43.607
They are crowded.

00:21:43.819 --> 00:21:45.907
There was one guy that I was helping out.

00:21:45.907 --> 00:21:47.643
He was a kindergarten teacher.

00:21:47.643 --> 00:22:05.707
He had 32 kindergartners in his class, at least two or three of them with some fairly significant learning issues, and you know, I don't know, I don't know how he managed to do it, but then we had a strike here locally.

00:22:05.707 --> 00:22:09.803
Teachers got most of what they wanted and the next time I went to his class.

00:22:09.803 --> 00:22:13.170
It was half as big as what it was before and things were under control.

00:22:13.170 --> 00:22:18.942
So you know, that was that kind of tells you a little bit about what's needed.

00:22:20.563 --> 00:22:32.309
I'm also of mixed opinion when it comes to the use of computers in class, especially these kindergartners.

00:22:32.309 --> 00:22:45.073
One of the things when I was helping out with this gentleman when his class had 32 kids in it, they're all trying to get these kindergartners logged in on their iPads into the network.

00:22:45.073 --> 00:22:53.653
And look, I'm sorry, asking 32 kindergartners to log into a network is like asking a starfish to do brain surgery.

00:22:53.653 --> 00:22:55.942
Yes, it's just not.

00:22:55.942 --> 00:22:59.331
You know, it took 45 minutes just to get them all logged in.

00:22:59.331 --> 00:23:02.922
And it wasn't just the kids, you know there were.

00:23:02.922 --> 00:23:12.812
Some of the computers were glitchy, some of the software wasn't working right, and every time something like that happens it adds another five minutes of delay.

00:23:13.519 --> 00:23:14.081
Exactly.

00:23:14.081 --> 00:23:16.870
They're taking away from the actual learning process.

00:23:17.179 --> 00:23:18.182
Right, they really are.

00:23:18.182 --> 00:23:25.554
So I'm kind of I'm kind of dubious about how computers are being used.

00:23:25.554 --> 00:23:32.113
I think there's a place for them, but I think it needs to be more carefully and more deliberately thought through.

00:23:32.680 --> 00:23:34.366
Right, especially at that young age.

00:23:34.366 --> 00:23:36.372
Yeah, yeah, definitely at that young age.

00:23:36.372 --> 00:23:38.823
Oh, my gosh, five years old, I'm thinking back to when.

00:23:38.823 --> 00:23:40.125
I was in kindergarten.

00:23:40.125 --> 00:23:44.260
Yeah, we definitely didn't use computers.

00:23:44.260 --> 00:23:54.542
They were more concerned about getting us to learn shapes, numbers, colors, things like that, the basics, and instead of trying to navigate an iPad.

00:23:54.742 --> 00:23:57.269
Yeah, that's true, and I have a friend.

00:23:57.269 --> 00:24:12.161
Her little boy is going to be nine in January but when he was two he had a tablet that he I was like two, she would give him a tablet and, yeah, now he loves it for everything and I'm like I don't know.

00:24:12.541 --> 00:24:13.122
I'd agree with you.

00:24:13.122 --> 00:24:14.523
I have my opinions on that too.

00:24:14.523 --> 00:24:18.366
I'm like there has to be a balance somewhere and limits, and I don't know.

00:24:18.366 --> 00:24:24.911
It's just that's kind of young to expose them to technology when they don't fully understand different things yet.

00:24:24.911 --> 00:24:30.295
To understand the implications of technology and what it can do, yeah, yeah.

00:24:30.836 --> 00:24:34.663
Now, funny story when I was in first grade I was having some trouble with math.

00:24:34.663 --> 00:24:38.111
This was in the early 60s, so that kind of dates me.

00:24:38.111 --> 00:24:50.467
But my parents went to talk to the teacher who was in charge of the math teaching the math in our classroom and they were concerned.

00:24:50.467 --> 00:24:57.726
And the teacher said oh, don't worry, by the time he's an adult, everyone will have their own computer and it won't matter.

00:24:57.726 --> 00:25:00.753
Well, she was half right.

00:25:00.753 --> 00:25:03.926
Yeah, she was.

00:25:03.926 --> 00:25:06.834
Yeah, she had the first part right yeah.

00:25:06.855 --> 00:25:07.837
Just not the second part.

00:25:08.218 --> 00:25:08.359
Yeah.

00:25:08.599 --> 00:25:20.106
That's funny, yeah, and I wonder what you know what you mentioned about just the challenges of K through 12 education, if that's why so many students that I get in my classes are in K through 12 education.

00:25:20.106 --> 00:25:31.584
I would say 80% of them are getting the master's in instructional design because they want to come out of the classroom and it's so sad to hear that that they want to, that they're burned out.

00:25:31.905 --> 00:25:34.049
You know, like you said, that they don't get enough pay.

00:25:34.049 --> 00:25:35.632
And for what they do?

00:25:35.632 --> 00:25:36.233
I agree.

00:25:36.233 --> 00:25:39.368
And sometimes even in higher education too.

00:25:39.368 --> 00:25:43.686
You know, I work, I work as an adjunct faculty and I love what I do.

00:25:43.686 --> 00:25:47.303
And they say you don't go into education for the money, that's for sure.

00:25:47.303 --> 00:25:49.226
But I agree it's.

00:25:49.226 --> 00:25:53.411
There needs to be that compensation for what they're putting into it.

00:25:53.411 --> 00:25:55.454
And so, yeah, so it's.

00:25:55.454 --> 00:25:56.375
It's tough.

00:25:56.375 --> 00:26:02.899
And I read some of the discussion questions and the things that they are going through and they face and it's like, oh, my goodness, they're still.

00:26:02.899 --> 00:26:07.071
They're still dealing with the effects of COVID, even almost six years later.

00:26:07.721 --> 00:26:08.464
And so it's.

00:26:08.464 --> 00:26:14.303
It's had a lasting impact on learning and and behavior and all those different aspects.

00:26:14.323 --> 00:26:38.605
So you've probably seen that too, and just the ripple effects of it teachers, which I find astonishing given that we have literal, empirical proof that there are teachers out there who are literally willing to take a bullet for their kids.

00:26:38.605 --> 00:26:41.672
That's just heinous.

00:26:41.672 --> 00:26:44.000
It's unacceptable.

00:26:44.942 --> 00:26:46.303
Yeah, absolutely yeah.

00:26:46.303 --> 00:27:01.250
Let's hope that we can improve education and make it so that you know, because it's you know it's interesting because administrators and schools they focus so much on test scores, right, and outcomes and everything else and that's important.

00:27:01.250 --> 00:27:07.692
But if there isn't something the research behind that, to see why are test scores so low.

00:27:07.692 --> 00:27:15.286
Because you know, I read articles too, you know about the state of education and then it's like what's going on?

00:27:15.286 --> 00:27:16.530
Why is there such a disconnect?

00:27:16.530 --> 00:27:17.541
So it's very interesting.

00:27:17.541 --> 00:27:32.188
Yeah, hopefully they can get test scores to go up, because then when you see other countries like China and North Korea, and they, their students, are so much higher in math and science, and it's like, oh, that's, oh, that's a little scary.

00:27:32.188 --> 00:27:42.667
We need to improve that and get them to a higher level so that they can be ready for college, if that's what they want to do, or go to a trade school or something like that.

00:27:42.667 --> 00:27:44.413
So yeah, it's interesting.

00:27:45.079 --> 00:27:54.991
Wow, yeah, so what kind of prompted you to develop your particular approach to learning in the life of the mind, like when you wrote your book, or just in general?

00:27:55.659 --> 00:27:57.106
Yeah, well, there were a couple of things.

00:27:57.106 --> 00:28:01.510
One was necessity, like I mentioned before.

00:28:01.510 --> 00:28:07.132
But there was another book that I encountered early in my doctoral program.

00:28:07.132 --> 00:28:09.499
It was written by Ronald Gross.

00:28:09.499 --> 00:28:15.983
It was called the Independent Scholar's Handbook and it was first published in 1982.

00:28:15.983 --> 00:28:19.125
And he people who were scholars but who were not part of academia.

00:28:19.125 --> 00:28:43.670
So an example, he gives several examples.

00:28:43.670 --> 00:28:52.574
One was Buckminster Fuller, the engineer who invented the geodesic dome and God knows how many other incredible inventions.

00:28:52.574 --> 00:28:54.919
He basically worked independently.

00:28:54.919 --> 00:29:02.591
It wasn't until very later, much later in his life, that he got any kind of professorship or anything.

00:29:02.591 --> 00:29:16.040
There was the historian Barbara Tuckman, who wrote some marvelous historical books A Distant Mirror, about the 13th century, I think.

00:29:16.040 --> 00:29:39.997
It was one called Fire and Sword, about Palestine, about the Zimmerman Telegram, about the Guns of August, which was this classic study of how World War I broke out, classic study of how World War I broke out, which, incidentally, john F Kennedy had just finished reading about the time the Cuban Missile Crisis came about.

00:29:40.558 --> 00:29:40.779
Oh, wow.

00:29:40.980 --> 00:29:43.563
And this kind of influenced him.

00:29:43.563 --> 00:29:56.092
He understood from her book how easily certain things that are designed to prevent things from spinning out of control could actually have the opposite effect.

00:29:56.092 --> 00:30:08.786
In the book she talks about how all these alliances were designed to keep wars from happening, but then, at the end of the day, they actually caused it to happen, and so.

00:30:08.786 --> 00:30:27.439
Another example was an American philosopher named Eric Hoffer who wrote a book called the True Believer, which is still considered a standard work for anyone who's studying the nature of mass movements and political science.

00:30:27.439 --> 00:30:30.043
He was a dock worker in San Francisco.

00:30:30.865 --> 00:30:35.972
But he, that's amazing he read very widely and he came up with this amazing stuff.

00:30:35.972 --> 00:30:46.058
Well, in many cases there's still a lot of truth to that, and I would kind of like to see more of that happen.

00:30:46.058 --> 00:30:50.326
I'd like to see more of it recognized and maybe kickstarted a little.

00:30:50.326 --> 00:31:02.175
Right, there's some very interesting things going on that a lot of people aren't aware of, that I think are, frankly, kind of inspiring, if nothing else.

00:31:02.857 --> 00:31:08.668
Right, exactly, and can help inspire the next writer, the next researcher.

00:31:08.668 --> 00:31:15.543
Yeah, exactly, writer, the next researcher, you know?

00:31:15.543 --> 00:31:19.611
Yeah, yeah, exactly, because we don't want certain industries to to to die away and to just go off into the distance.

00:31:19.611 --> 00:31:24.236
You know we still need all these different areas, so yeah, being able to have that.

00:31:24.236 --> 00:31:24.779
That's important.

00:31:25.340 --> 00:31:26.564
And we need fresh ideas.

00:31:26.564 --> 00:31:32.276
We need places where people can can kick around ideas that no one else is thinking about.

00:31:33.420 --> 00:31:43.211
That's true, yeah, and to come together and form those ideas, yeah, that's important, because we're meant to be in a community and not meant to be in isolation.

00:31:43.211 --> 00:31:43.952
So that's important.

00:31:43.952 --> 00:31:46.515
Yes, yeah, absolutely.

00:31:46.515 --> 00:31:59.163
I love that to a field, whether it's in education or instructional design.

00:31:59.163 --> 00:32:02.791
Or maybe they're just starting out in the field of education or instructional design in particular.

00:32:04.740 --> 00:32:08.183
I would say a couple of things.

00:32:08.183 --> 00:32:20.945
One is to read widely about what's been going on in education, not just currently, but in its history, find out how we got here.

00:32:20.945 --> 00:32:27.279
Now, I am by no means any kind of authority when it comes to instructional design.

00:32:27.279 --> 00:32:38.423
When I was working on Henley Putnam University, I was designing courses, but it was pretty much by the seat of my pants and I was talking to people and saying subject matter, please help me.

00:32:38.423 --> 00:32:44.625
And I became intimately familiar with Bloom's taxonomy and stuff like that.

00:32:44.625 --> 00:32:50.689
But much of what I learned I kind of learned the hard way.

00:32:50.689 --> 00:32:58.154
Who are actually on the line, on the firing line, as it were.

00:32:58.154 --> 00:33:21.372
Ask them what works, ask them what works, ask them what they love, ask them what they hate, and shape what you're doing accordingly, because I'm afraid that so much of the material that I see looks kind of like it was designed in isolation from the classroom.

00:33:21.372 --> 00:33:26.551
Not all of it, but enough of it to kind of make me wince a little.

00:33:27.360 --> 00:33:28.284
Yes, I would agree.

00:33:28.866 --> 00:33:32.024
Yeah, so you know for what it's worth.

00:33:32.024 --> 00:33:35.211
That's the best I can give you at this point.

00:33:35.792 --> 00:33:49.367
I love that, yeah, and having that novice approach to the subject, because for me my experience is in business and then education in the sense of the instructional design and e-learning, things like that.

00:33:49.367 --> 00:33:54.290
But I work on programs and courses in counseling, social work, psychology.

00:33:54.290 --> 00:34:06.024
I have a little bit of that psychology background because of the business and the marketing, because we learn about the psychology behind why people make decisions the way they do and fire behavior, things like that.

00:34:06.024 --> 00:34:13.820
So I have a little bit of that psychology background, but not to the extent that these people do that, our subject matter experts and our faculty.

00:34:13.820 --> 00:34:32.605
So I love that you brought that up, that don't create that content in isolation and collaborate with people and find out, like you said, once you implement it, go back to it and evaluate it and see what's working whether it's formative or summative evaluation and see what's effective, what's not.

00:34:32.605 --> 00:34:34.126
Do we need to make adjustments?

00:34:34.126 --> 00:34:38.534
Because refinement is always important to do.

00:34:39.139 --> 00:34:40.887
Yeah, it's an ongoing process.

00:34:40.887 --> 00:34:43.749
A curriculum is a living thing.

00:34:44.519 --> 00:34:45.684
Right, absolutely.

00:34:45.684 --> 00:35:03.309
So, true, yeah, so I always like to take that novice approach and not feel like I know so much about the content that I lose that curiosity and that sense of asking questions, because then if I think I know the answer, I'm not going to ask the question, right, yeah?

00:35:03.309 --> 00:35:22.427
So being able to have that sense of always wanting to learn more, even though I may know some of the terminology I don't know to the depth that they do because they're in the field, they're working and they're teaching every day, and so it would be like someone trying to teach my class on instructional design, and not everybody can do that.

00:35:22.427 --> 00:35:29.374
So we all have our talents and our skills that we're able to bring to the table.

00:35:29.374 --> 00:35:31.144
So it's really great to have that.

00:35:32.789 --> 00:35:33.711
Exactly yeah.

00:35:34.521 --> 00:35:38.443
And being able to recognize that we all work together, so it's a team effort.

00:35:39.186 --> 00:35:40.110
Yeah, it's wonderful.

00:35:40.110 --> 00:35:42.606
It is a communal effort, no doubt about it.

00:35:43.088 --> 00:36:09.061
Right, exactly, yeah, no-transcript need to have.

00:36:09.643 --> 00:36:22.528
And then I take that and I put that raw data into our closed system AI tool and I'll ask it can you come up with some of the key themes and key information from that?

00:36:22.528 --> 00:36:38.269
And it'll give me a document and then I present that in the kickoff meeting and I say, based on the raw data which you can view and I can show you that, but here's a high level overview of that, so that way I'm not overwhelming them with a bunch of raw data, because a lot of them don't like that.

00:36:38.780 --> 00:36:49.581
They just want to know what's the gist of it, and then from there we just kind of move along, and I utilize that to inform different aspects of it and to make sure we're on track, and so it's really neat.

00:36:49.581 --> 00:37:06.206
So we had a meeting today and we went over the domains and competencies, finalized those and we worked those out, and all the drafts were based on AI, and so I said you know, it's only going to be as good as what I ask it to do and what my knowledge is, but you guys are the experts.

00:37:06.206 --> 00:37:11.000
You know what's needed and what is going to work for the students.

00:37:11.000 --> 00:37:16.869
So we tweaked all you know some of the things, we rearranged things and I'm like that's what this is all about.

00:37:16.869 --> 00:37:20.733
This is what true collaboration is about, and I need your expertise.

00:37:21.375 --> 00:37:26.321
Yeah, so it was a.

00:37:26.321 --> 00:37:32.327
It's a great experience when you can take that and you can utilize everyone's knowledge and skills and their expertise and really make it the best curriculum it can be for the students.

00:37:32.327 --> 00:37:39.068
I always like to imagine them as a, with their graduation cap on, and so that was something my my coworker did.

00:37:39.068 --> 00:37:43.160
He drew it on the board and he's like we're here, let's imagine them as a graduate.

00:37:43.160 --> 00:37:53.126
So it's always that, that nice picture of being able to imagine them walking down that you know that aisle and getting getting their cap and gown, you know.

00:37:53.167 --> 00:37:55.010
Yeah, it's a great feeling.

00:37:55.431 --> 00:37:58.082
Yeah, absolutely yeah, that's great.

00:37:58.082 --> 00:37:59.968
Well, I enjoyed this conversation.

00:37:59.968 --> 00:38:03.168
This is wonderful, sheldon, thank you so much for sharing your insights today.

00:38:03.168 --> 00:38:07.878
Your experiences, tips and expertise are sure to inspire my listeners, so.

00:38:07.938 --> 00:38:08.280
I appreciate that.

00:38:08.280 --> 00:38:09.847
Well, thank you, jackie, it was a pleasure.

00:38:10.940 --> 00:38:11.603
Great Thank you.

00:38:11.603 --> 00:38:22.809
I look forward to having you back again on the show, because whenever I have someone on my show, it seems like we want to do another episode and continue the conversation, so I welcome that opportunity again.

00:38:23.731 --> 00:38:24.613
I look forward to it.

00:38:25.280 --> 00:38:26.506
Thank you so much, appreciate it.

00:38:26.506 --> 00:38:30.911
Thank you for taking some time to listen to this podcast episode today.

00:38:30.911 --> 00:38:33.245
Your support means the world to me.

00:38:33.245 --> 00:38:41.990
If you'd like to help keep the podcast going, you can share it with a friend or colleague, leave a heartfelt review or offer a monetary contribution.

00:38:41.990 --> 00:38:49.076
Every act of support, big or small, makes a difference and I'm truly thankful for you.

Dr. Sheldon Greaves Profile Photo

Dr. Sheldon Greaves

Educator and Author

Dr. Sheldon Greaves is the author of The Guerrilla Scholar's Handbook. He earned a Ph.D. from the University of California at Berkeley while living and working in Silicon Valley during the dot.com boom. Pursuing his doctorate on a shoestring while indulging other interests, he developed a different approach to a life of the mind. Throughout his long and varied career, Sheldon has used the tools of “guerrilla scholarship” to do interesting intellectual work outside of academia.

The Guerrilla Scholar's Handbook is part how-to, part memoir, and part manifesto that celebrates the pleasures and perils of the independent life of the mind. It also endorses communal learning as a way of strengthening and enlivening society at a time when the very idea of education and expertise is under siege.