Designing Effective Learning: A Deep Dive into the Dick and Carey Model
The Dick and Carey Systems Approach Model has remained a cornerstone of instructional design since its introduction in 1978. Unlike linear approaches to creating learning experiences, this model embraces a systematic perspective where each component influences the others, much like ingredients in a well-crafted recipe. For instructional designers, especially those new to the field, understanding and implementing this model provides structure without sacrificing creativity.
At its core, the Dick and Carey model views instructional design as an interconnected system rather than a simple step-by-step process. This distinction is crucial because it acknowledges the complex reality of learning design: changing one element inevitably impacts all others. The model emphasizes data-informed decision-making across the entire instructional lifecycle, from initial analysis through evaluation. This holistic approach ensures that nothing is overlooked and that all design choices serve specific learning purposes.
The eight core principles of the model provide a comprehensive framework for creating effective instruction. Beginning with systematic design, designers must ensure every element serves a purpose within the broader learning experience. The second principle focuses on thoroughly analyzing learner characteristics through research, surveys, and creating detailed learner profiles. The third principle emphasizes defining clear, measurable instructional objectives that guide everyone involved in the process. These foundations set the stage for organizing instructional content (principle four), which creates a logical flow that builds knowledge progressively without confusing learners.
Selecting appropriate instructional strategies constitutes the fifth principle, where designers choose methods that align with learning theories and the specific needs of their audience. The sixth principle covers development and implementation – the creation of learning materials that help learners achieve performance objectives. Principles seven and eight address evaluation: formative evaluation tests materials with a small group before full implementation, while summative evaluation assesses the overall effectiveness after implementation. Each principle intentionally feeds into the next, creating a cohesive approach to instructional design.
For beginners, the Dick and Carey model offers tremendous value through its structured approach. When entering a complex field like instructional design, having a clear process provides necessary guidance and confidence. The model's emphasis on thoughtful planning, continuous feedback, and alignment between goals and assessments reflects real-world workflows in both academic and corporate environments. This relevance makes it particularly valuable for those transitioning into professional instructional design roles where data-driven outcomes matter.
Implementing the model effectively requires attention to several key practices. First, resist the temptation to skip the front-end analysis (principles 1-3), as understanding learning goals, required skills, and learner characteristics forms the foundation for everything that follows. Second, create specific, measurable objectives using action verbs like "describe," "analyze," or "demonstrate" that clearly define what success looks like. Third, ensure alignment between objectives, assessments, and learning strategies to maintain consistency throughout the design. Fourth, conduct small-scale formative evaluations and be prepared to make changes based on feedback. Fifth, utilize available templates and tools to organize each stage without requiring expensive software. Finally, remember to use the model flexibly rather than rigidly, adapting it to the constraints and realities of each unique project.
The Dick and Carey model's enduring relevance speaks to its effectiveness in creating intentional, learner-centered instruction. By viewing instructional design as a system rather than a linear process, designers can create more cohesive and effective learning experiences. As Orison Swett Marden wisely noted, "A good system shortens the road to the goal." The Dick and Carey model doesn't shorten this road by skipping steps, but by providing a clear roadmap that leads to intentional and successful learning outcomes. For both new and experienced instructional designers, it remains an invaluable framework for approaching the complex task of creating meaningful learning experiences.
🔗 Episode Links:
Please check out the resources mentioned in the episode. Enjoy!
An In-Depth Analysis of the Dick and Carey Model
📑 References:
Pappas, C. (2024, February 28). An In-Depth analysis of the Dick and Carey model. eLearning Industry. https://elearningindustry.com/an-in-depth-analysis-of-the-dick-and-carey-model
Photo by picjumbo.com: https://www.pexels.com/photo/notebook-beside-the-iphone-on-table-196644/
Jackie Pelegrin
Instructional Designer, Author, College Professor, and Podcast Host
Jackie, an Arizona native, leverages decades of experience as an instructional designer within both higher education and the corporate world. She holds an MBA and a Master of Science in Instructional Design and Technology, both acquired through online learning. In addition to her full-time role, Jackie serves as an adjunct instructor, teaching online courses at Grand Canyon University. During her leisure time, she delights in reading books across a range of genres, enjoying movies and TV shows, playing games, listening to uplifting music, and spending quality time with her family and friends.
Needs Analysis and Learner Personas: Your Secret Weapon for Effective Learning
